Bulletproof Coffee Side Effects: Managing Jitters

Quick answer

• Bulletproof coffee’s high fat and caffeine content can lead to jitters, anxiety, and digestive issues for some individuals.
• Adjusting the amount of butter, MCT oil, and caffeine is the primary way to manage these side effects.
• Starting with smaller amounts of MCT oil and gradually increasing can help your digestive system adapt.
• Ensure your coffee is brewed properly to avoid over-extraction, which can increase bitterness and perceived harshness.
• Listen to your body; if side effects persist, bulletproof coffee might not be the right choice for you.
• Combining bulletproof coffee with other high-caffeine beverages can exacerbate jitters.

What this problem usually is (and is not)

• This issue is typically a reaction to the concentrated fat and caffeine in bulletproof coffee, not a sign of a faulty coffee maker.
• It’s not a sign that your coffee maker is broken or that the coffee beans are inherently bad.
• The “jitters” are a physiological response to stimulants and rich fats, not a mechanical failure of your brewing equipment.
• This problem is about your personal tolerance and the composition of your drink, rather than a brewing defect.
• It’s important to distinguish between a “bad brew” (e.g., bitter, weak) and the side effects of the ingredients themselves.
• This guide focuses on managing the side effects of the bulletproof coffee recipe, not troubleshooting general coffee brewing problems like clogs or leaks.

Likely causes (triage list)

Caffeine Overload:

• Too much coffee: Using more grounds than recommended for your brew size or brewing a very strong batch can increase caffeine. Confirm by checking your coffee-to-water ratio.
• High-caffeine beans: Some bean varieties naturally have more caffeine. Review your bean source if you’ve recently switched.

Fat Content Sensitivity:

• Excessive MCT oil: Starting with too much MCT oil can overwhelm your digestive system. Check the amount of MCT oil you’re adding.
• Too much butter: While often less problematic than MCT oil, a very large amount of butter can also contribute to digestive discomfort. Measure your butter.
• Combined fats: The synergistic effect of MCT oil and butter can be more intense than either alone. Consider the total fat volume.

While often less problematic than MCT oil, a very large amount of grass-fed butter can also contribute to digestive discomfort. Measure your butter to ensure you’re using the right amount.

Kerrygold Grass-Fed Pure Irish Salted Butter Sticks, 16 OZ

• KERRYGOLD PURE IRISH SALTED BUTTER: Our European-style salted butter is made on family farms from the milk of grass-fed cows, who graze year round on lush Irish pastures, for a golden yellow butter that's rich & creamy.
• ALL-NATURAL, ALL-PURPOSE: Kerrygold Salted Butter is a great all-purpose, all-natural butter. Keep a block in your butter dish to spread on fresh bread, or enhance the flavor of your baking & cooking.
• KERRYGOLD BUTTER: Made from the milk of grass-fed cows, our pure Irish butter is rich and soft. From salted butter to unsalted, garlic and herb to reduced fat, Kerrygold butter elevates your dishes.
• MORE THAN BUTTER: Beloved for our richly flavorful butter, we put the same care and quality into our all-natural cheese, like our classic Dubliner, aged cheddar, Swiss, and Blarney Castle cheese.
• TASTE THE DIFFERENCE: Kerrygold butter & cheese are made with milk from grass-fed cows not treated with rBST or other growth hormones* & raised on Irish family dairy farms. This all-natural milk is what makes our products so flavorful & creamy.

Buy on Amazon

Brewing Technique:

• Over-extraction: Brewing at too high a temperature or too long can result in a bitter, harsh cup that can feel more stimulating. Check your brew temperature and time.
• Under-extraction: While less common for jitters, an under-extracted brew can be sour and unpleasant, potentially leading to discomfort. Assess your grind size and brew time.

Machine Setup and Maintenance:

• No direct impact: Your coffee maker’s functionality doesn’t directly cause bulletproof coffee jitters, but a poorly maintained machine could lead to a less pleasant tasting coffee that exacerbates the feeling.

Fix it step-by-step (brew workflow)

1. Assess your current recipe:

• What to do: Before brewing, review the exact amounts of coffee, butter, MCT oil, and any other additions you used in your last problematic cup.
• What “good” looks like: You have a clear understanding of your ingredient quantities.
• Common mistake: Guessing amounts instead of measuring. Avoid it by: Using measuring spoons and a scale for accuracy.

2. Reduce caffeine source:

• What to do: If you used a standard drip machine, try using slightly fewer coffee grounds for the same amount of water, or brew a slightly larger batch. If using a French press, steep for a slightly shorter time.
• What “good” looks like: You’ve made a quantifiable reduction in the potential caffeine dose.
• Common mistake: Not knowing how much coffee you typically use. Avoid it by: Weighing your coffee grounds before brewing.

3. Lower MCT oil amount:

• What to do: If you used 1-2 tablespoons of MCT oil, reduce it to 1 teaspoon or even ½ teaspoon for your next attempt.
• What “good” looks like: You’ve significantly decreased the amount of MCT oil.
• Common mistake: Adding MCT oil directly from the bottle without measuring. Avoid it by: Using a teaspoon to measure precisely.

4. Maintain butter quantity (initially):

• What to do: For this first adjustment, keep the butter amount consistent with your usual recipe, assuming it wasn’t excessively high.
• What “good” looks like: You’re isolating variables by changing only one thing at a time.
• Common mistake: Changing both MCT oil and butter amounts simultaneously. Avoid it by: Adjusting one ingredient at a time.

5. Brew your coffee:

• What to do: Use your standard brewing method and machine, ensuring it’s clean.
• What “good” looks like: The coffee brews without any unusual noises or smells from the machine.
• Common mistake: Brewing with a dirty machine. Avoid it by: Performing regular cleaning as per your machine’s manual.

6. Blend carefully:

• What to do: Add your reduced MCT oil and standard butter to the brewed coffee in a blender. Blend on medium to high speed until emulsified.
• What “good” looks like: The drink has a creamy, frothy texture with no visible oil separation.
• Common mistake: Not blending long enough. Avoid it by: Blending for at least 30-60 seconds to fully emulsify.

7. Taste and evaluate:

• What to do: Sip your adjusted bulletproof coffee slowly. Pay attention to how you feel physically and mentally.
• What “good” looks like: You experience significantly reduced jitters or none at all.
• Common mistake: Drinking it too quickly. Avoid it by: Sipping it over 15-20 minutes to allow your body to process it.

8. Adjust further if needed:

• What to do: If you still experience mild jitters, consider further reducing MCT oil or slightly decreasing the coffee amount. If you felt fine, you can gradually increase MCT oil by ½ teaspoon increments in future brews until you find your sweet spot.
• What “good” looks like: You’ve found a balance that works for your body.
• Common mistake: Giving up too soon or pushing your limits. Avoid it by: Making small, incremental adjustments and listening to your body’s signals.

Prevent it next time

• Start Low and Go Slow with MCT Oil: Begin with ½ to 1 teaspoon of MCT oil and gradually increase by ½ teaspoon every few days as tolerated.
• Measure All Ingredients: Use a scale for coffee grounds and measuring spoons for butter and MCT oil to ensure consistency and control.
• Choose Your Coffee Wisely: If you’re sensitive to caffeine, opt for decaf or half-caf beans, or reduce the overall coffee volume.
• Brew Correctly: Ensure your coffee maker is clean and that you’re using the correct grind size and water temperature for your chosen brewing method.
• Hydrate: Drink plenty of water alongside your bulletproof coffee to help your body process the fats and caffeine.
• Listen to Your Body: Pay attention to how you feel. If you consistently experience jitters or discomfort, bulletproof coffee may not be suitable for you.
• Avoid Other Stimulants: Don’t consume other caffeinated beverages or high-sugar energy drinks around the same time.
• Regular Machine Cleaning: Keep your coffee maker clean to ensure optimal brewing and prevent off-flavors that could compound discomfort.
• Fresh Water: Use filtered or fresh, cold water for brewing. Avoid using water that has been sitting in the reservoir.

Common mistakes (and what happens if you ignore them)

Decision rules (simple if/then)

• If you experience jitters after your first bulletproof coffee, then reduce the MCT oil to ½ teaspoon for your next attempt because MCT oil is a common trigger for digestive and stimulant side effects.
• If jitters persist after reducing MCT oil, then also slightly reduce the amount of coffee grounds because caffeine is a primary stimulant.
• If your bulletproof coffee tastes bitter, then check your grind size and brew time because over-extraction can lead to bitterness and a harsher taste.
• If you experience stomach cramps, then reduce the MCT oil and ensure you are not consuming it on an empty stomach because MCT oil can be difficult to digest for some.
• If you feel anxious, then reduce both the MCT oil and the caffeine content because the combination can be overstimulating.
• If your bulletproof coffee separates, then blend it for a longer duration because proper emulsification requires sufficient blending time.
• If you are new to bulletproof coffee, then start with a very small amount of MCT oil (¼ to ½ teaspoon) and gradually increase because your body needs time to adapt.
• If you experience no jitters with a small amount of MCT oil, then you can slowly increase the MCT oil by ½ teaspoon increments every few days because this allows you to find your optimal dose.
• If you are highly sensitive to caffeine, then consider using decaffeinated or half-caffeinated coffee beans because this will significantly lower your stimulant intake.
• If you notice a metallic taste, then clean your coffee maker thoroughly because residue can affect the coffee’s flavor.
• If jitters are accompanied by heart palpitations, then stop consuming bulletproof coffee immediately and consult a healthcare professional because this can be a sign of overstimulation.

FAQ

Q: Does bulletproof coffee make you jittery?

A: Yes, it can. The combination of caffeine from coffee and the high fat content (butter and MCT oil) can be very stimulating for some individuals, leading to jitters and anxiety.

Q: How much MCT oil is too much?

A: This varies greatly by individual tolerance. For beginners, starting with ½ to 1 teaspoon is recommended. Consuming more than 1-2 tablespoons at once can often lead to digestive upset and jitters.

Q: Can I use regular butter instead of grass-fed butter?

A: You can, but grass-fed butter is often recommended for its purported health benefits and flavor. Regular butter will still add fat, but may not offer the same profile or taste.

Q: What if I’m sensitive to caffeine?

A: If you’re sensitive to caffeine, you can use decaffeinated coffee or a half-caffeinated blend as the base for your bulletproof coffee. You can also reduce the overall coffee volume.

Q: Why does my bulletproof coffee taste greasy?

A: This usually happens if it’s not blended long enough. The fats need to be fully emulsified into a creamy, frothy consistency. Blend for at least 30-60 seconds.

Q: Can bulletproof coffee cause digestive issues besides jitters?

A: Yes, it can cause stomach cramps, bloating, and diarrhea, especially when starting with high amounts of MCT oil. This is because MCTs are rapidly absorbed and can be hard on the digestive system initially.

Q: Is it safe to drink bulletproof coffee every day?

A: For most people who tolerate it well, yes. However, if you experience persistent side effects, it’s best to limit or avoid it. Listen to your body’s signals.

Q: What’s the best way to adjust the recipe if I get jitters?

A: The most effective way is to gradually reduce the amount of MCT oil and/or caffeine. Make small adjustments and see how your body responds.

What this page does NOT cover (and where to go next)

• Specific coffee maker troubleshooting: This guide doesn’t address issues like leaks, slow brewing, or error codes for your particular coffee machine model. Consult your coffee maker’s manual or manufacturer support for these problems.
• Medical advice: If you experience severe adverse reactions like heart palpitations, chest pain, or extreme anxiety, discontinue use and consult a healthcare professional.
• Weight loss claims: While some proponents claim bulletproof coffee aids weight loss, this guide does not delve into nutritional science or specific dietary strategies.
• Advanced brewing techniques: This article focuses on managing ingredient side effects, not on advanced methods like pour-over optimization or espresso extraction.