Making Coffee-Flavored Whiskey at Home

Quick answer

• Start with a good quality, neutral whiskey. Bourbon or rye work well.
• Choose your coffee beans wisely. Freshly roasted, whole beans are key.
• Grind the beans coarse. Think French press grind, not espresso fine.
• Infuse for a short time. A few hours to a day is usually enough.
• Taste frequently. You don’t want bitter coffee overtaking the whiskey.
• Strain thoroughly. Use a fine-mesh sieve and maybe cheesecloth.
• Let it rest. Give the flavors time to meld after straining.

Who this is for

• Home bar enthusiasts looking to experiment.
• Whiskey lovers who enjoy a hint of coffee.
• Anyone who wants a unique cocktail ingredient without buying pre-made versions.

What to check first

Brewer type and filter type

This isn’t about brewing coffee to drink, but using coffee in whiskey. So, no specific brewer type matters here. What does matter is how you’ll separate the coffee grounds from the whiskey later. A fine-mesh sieve is a minimum. Cheesecloth or a coffee filter (like for a pour-over) can help get a cleaner result. Don’t skimp on this; nobody likes gritty whiskey.

Water quality and temperature

You’re not using water directly, but the quality of your whiskey matters. Use something you enjoy drinking on its own. For temperature, room temperature is fine for the infusion. You’ll chill the final product later if you want.

Grind size and coffee freshness

This is huge. Use whole beans and grind them right before you infuse. A coarse grind is best. Think about what you’d use for a French press. Too fine a grind releases too many bitter compounds too quickly. Freshness matters for flavor, but don’t use super light roasts unless you know what you’re doing – they can be tricky. Medium to dark roasts usually play nicer.

Coffee-to-water ratio

In this case, it’s coffee-to-whiskey ratio. A good starting point is about 1-2 ounces of whole coffee beans per 750ml bottle of whiskey. You can adjust this. Too much coffee, and it’ll be overpowering and bitter. Too little, and you won’t taste it.

Cleanliness/descale status

Make sure your infusion vessel and all straining tools are spotless. Any lingering flavors or residue can mess up your coffee whiskey. Think about it: you’re adding a strong flavor to an already complex spirit. You want control.

Step-by-step (how to make coffee whiskey)

1. Choose your whiskey. Grab a bottle you like. Bourbon or a decent rye are good choices. Avoid anything too smoky or heavily peated unless you’re going for a very specific flavor profile.

• What good looks like: You’ve got a clean, neutral-ish spirit ready to take on coffee notes.
• Common mistake: Using a cheap, harsh whiskey. It’ll just amplify the bad flavors.

Grab a bottle of quality rye whiskey you enjoy; it’s the perfect base for infusing those coffee notes.

Old State Farms Rye Whiskey Barrel Aged Pure Maple Syrup, 8.4oz, 250ML

• 100% PURE MAPLE SYRUP aged to perfection in recently emptied RYE WHISKEY barrels. We source our barrels from Wigle Whiskey, one of the nations most awarded small craft distilleries.
• Overtones of traditional American Rye Whiskey characteristics, layered with our signature Dark Robust pure maple syrup. Balanced yet edgy,
• Delicious over waffles, french toast, hot breakfast cereal, yogurt or fresh fruit. Add flare to vinaigrette dressings, BBQ sauce or grilled salmon.
• Crafted with care in small batches on our maple farm in NW Pennsylvania. Hand made, hand bottled, hand labeled.

Buy on Amazon

2. Select your coffee beans. Freshly roasted, whole beans. Medium to dark roast is usually a safe bet. Avoid flavored coffees.

• What good looks like: You have good quality beans that smell great.
• Common mistake: Using old, stale, pre-ground coffee. It’ll taste flat and bitter.

3. Grind the beans. Grind them coarsely. A burr grinder is ideal for consistency.

• What good looks like: Coarse, sand-like grounds. Not powder.
• Common mistake: Grinding too fine. This will over-extract and make your coffee whiskey bitter.

4. Combine whiskey and grounds. Put the coarsely ground coffee into a clean jar or container. Pour the whiskey over the grounds.

• What good looks like: All the grounds are submerged in the whiskey.
• Common mistake: Not using enough whiskey to cover the grounds. Some grounds might not infuse properly.

5. Infuse. Seal the container and let it sit at room temperature. Start checking after 4-6 hours.

• What good looks like: The whiskey is starting to take on a light brown color and a coffee aroma.
• Common mistake: Leaving it too long initially. You can always infuse more, but you can’t un-infuse.

6. Taste frequently. This is crucial. Swirl a small amount, smell it, and taste it. You’re looking for a pleasant coffee note that complements, not dominates, the whiskey.

• What good looks like: You can taste the coffee, but the whiskey’s character is still present.
• Common mistake: Forgetting to taste. You might end up with undrinkable bitter sludge.

7. Strain the solids. Once you’re happy with the flavor, it’s time to strain. Use a fine-mesh sieve first. For an even cleaner result, line the sieve with cheesecloth or a coffee filter and strain again.

• What good looks like: Clear or mostly clear liquid with no visible grounds.
• Common mistake: Rushing the straining process. This leaves sediment, which affects texture and flavor.

8. Discard the grounds. Compost them or throw them away.

• What good looks like: You’ve successfully removed all the coffee solids.
• Common mistake: Trying to re-use the grounds. They’ve given all their flavor.

9. Let it rest. Pour the strained coffee whiskey into a clean bottle or back into its original. Let it sit for at least 24 hours, preferably a few days, in a cool, dark place. This allows the flavors to meld and mellow.

• What good looks like: The flavors are integrated and smoother.
• Common mistake: Drinking it immediately. The flavors can be harsh and disjointed.

10. Chill and serve (optional). Serve it neat, on the rocks, or use it in cocktails. You can chill the bottle for a colder serving.

• What good looks like: A delicious, unique spirit ready to be enjoyed.
• Common mistake: Serving it too warm if you prefer it chilled.

Common mistakes (and what happens if you ignore them)

Decision rules (simple if/then)

• If your coffee whiskey tastes too bitter, then you likely infused for too long or used too fine a grind.
• If the coffee flavor is too weak, then you need to infuse for a bit longer or use slightly more coffee next time.
• If you see sediment in your final drink, then your straining wasn’t thorough enough.
• If the whiskey tastes harsh, then the base spirit might not have been ideal, or the coffee extraction was poor.
• If you want a stronger coffee flavor without more bitterness, then try a slightly darker roast next time.
• If you’re unsure about the infusion time, then start checking after 3 hours and taste every hour.
• If you want a smoother finish, then let the coffee whiskey rest for at least 48 hours.
• If you’re using a very high-proof whiskey, then it can handle a bit more coffee flavor without becoming too harsh.
• If you want to experiment with different coffee notes, then try single-origin beans but be aware they can be more delicate.
• If your coffee whiskey tastes “muddy,” then the coffee grounds might have been too fine or you didn’t strain well.
• If you’re making a large batch, then scale your coffee beans proportionally to the amount of whiskey.
• If you want to achieve a very clean flavor, then consider using a coffee filter after the initial sieve strain.

FAQ

How much coffee should I use?

A good starting point is 1 to 2 ounces of whole coffee beans per 750ml bottle of whiskey. You can adjust this based on your taste preferences.

How long should I infuse the coffee?

This varies. Start tasting after 4-6 hours. Some people go up to 24 hours, but it’s easy to over-extract. It’s better to infuse for a shorter time and add more if needed.

What kind of whiskey is best?

Bourbon or rye whiskey are generally recommended because their flavor profiles complement coffee well. Avoid heavily peated Scotch unless you’re aiming for a very specific, intense flavor.

Can I use pre-ground coffee?

It’s strongly discouraged. Pre-ground coffee loses freshness quickly and can lead to a stale, bitter taste. Always grind whole beans just before you start.

What if my coffee whiskey is too bitter?

This usually means it was infused for too long or the grind was too fine. Strain it immediately. For the next batch, reduce infusion time or use a coarser grind.

How do I strain out the coffee grounds effectively?

Use a fine-mesh sieve first. For an even clearer result, line the sieve with cheesecloth or a paper coffee filter and strain again.

Does the coffee flavor fade over time?

The coffee flavor will likely mellow and integrate with the whiskey over time, rather than fading away. Letting it rest for a few days or weeks helps this process.

Can I make a decaf coffee whiskey?

Yes, absolutely. Use decaffeinated coffee beans. Just be aware that decaffeination processes can sometimes alter the bean’s flavor profile.

What cocktails work well with coffee whiskey?

It’s great in variations of an Old Fashioned, Manhattan, or even a simple whiskey sour. It also adds a nice twist to coffee-based cocktails.

What this page does NOT cover (and where to go next)

• Specific brand recommendations for whiskey or coffee beans. (Next: Research highly-rated bourbons or ryes, and explore local roasters.)
• Advanced techniques like cold brew infusion or using coffee extracts. (Next: Look into specialized coffee brewing guides or bartender forums.)
• Detailed flavor profiles of different coffee varietals and how they interact with whiskey. (Next: Explore coffee tasting notes and whiskey tasting guides.)
• Commercial production methods or legal considerations for selling your creation. (Next: Consult with legal or business advisors if you plan to sell.)
• Recipes for specific coffee whiskey cocktails. (Next: Search for “coffee whiskey cocktail recipes” online.)