Delicious Homemade Coffee Pudding Recipe

Quick answer

• Use fresh, good-quality coffee.
• Get the ratio of coffee to other ingredients right.
• Heat the milk and coffee mixture gently.
• Don’t overcook the pudding.
• Chill thoroughly before serving.
• Taste and adjust sweetness.

Who this is for

• Anyone who loves coffee and dessert.
• Home cooks looking for a simple, yet impressive treat.
• People who want to use up leftover coffee.

This recipe is perfect for anyone who loves coffee and wants to create a delicious homemade dessert.

David's Cookies Fresh Baked Decadent Jumbo Assorted — Flavorful Gourmet Cookies - Ideal Food Gift for Corporate, Birthday, Fathers and Mothers Day, Get Well and Other Special Occasions — 2 lb (8 pcs)

• FRESHLY BAKED COOKIES - Indulge in David's Cookies Assorted Fresh-Baked Gift Basket. An elegant tin holds a variety of large, decadent cookies, crafted with care and expertise, our cookies offer a sumptuous treat for the taste buds.
• GIFT PACK CONTAINS 3 DELICIOUS FLAVORS: David’s Cookies assorted cookie gift tin contains 8 – 4.5 oz. freshly soft-baked cookies in 3 delicious flavors including Triple Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Chunk, and S'mores
• NO ADDED PRESERVATIVES - Free from added preservatives, each cookie is a testament to the richness of premium, carefully selected ingredients. Savor the richness of flavors that are uncompromised, and bask in the indulgent, fresh-baked aroma.
• GIFT FOR ANY OCCASION - Make any occasion extra special with our delightful cookie gift basket. Whether it's corporate gifting, celebrating birthdays, expressing your get-well wishes, or simply brightening someone's day, our cookie basket serves as an ideal gift.
• QUALITY INGREDIENTS - We believe that the best cookies come from the best ingredients. We meticulously source the finest components for our cookies, allowing us to deliver a product that is not only delicious but also maintains a standard of quality that sets us apart.

Buy on Amazon

What to check first

Brewer type and filter type

This recipe is pretty forgiving, but the coffee you use matters. Drip coffee, French press, or even espresso will work. Just make sure your coffee maker is clean. A paper filter for drip coffee is fine, but if you use a French press, make sure you’ve strained out most of the grounds. Nobody wants grit in their pudding.

Water quality and temperature

Use filtered water for your coffee if possible. Tap water can sometimes have off-flavors that will come through. For brewing the coffee itself, follow your usual method. The temperature is more about getting a good extraction for the coffee flavor, not so much about the final pudding temp.

Grind size and coffee freshness

Freshly ground beans are always best. For drip or pour-over, a medium grind is usually good. If you’re using a French press, a coarser grind is better. Stale coffee just won’t give you that rich flavor we’re after.

Coffee-to-water ratio

This recipe calls for brewed coffee. A good starting point is about 1 cup of strong brewed coffee. If you usually brew weaker coffee, you might want to use a little less water when brewing it for the pudding recipe, or brew it double-strength. We need that coffee flavor to shine.

Cleanliness/descale status

Make sure your coffee maker is clean. Any residue can impart weird flavors. Also, your pots and pans for making the pudding should be spotless. A clean slate means the pure coffee and dessert flavors will come through.

Step-by-step (brew workflow)

This isn’t a “brew workflow” in the coffee-making sense, but rather how you make the pudding itself. Let’s get this dessert rolling.

1. Brew Strong Coffee: Brew about 1 cup of strong coffee using your preferred method.

• What “good” looks like: Rich, dark coffee with a good aroma. Not watery.
• Common mistake: Brewing weak coffee. Avoid this by using a bit more grounds or a bit less water than usual.

2. Gather Ingredients: Get out your sugar, cornstarch, milk, eggs, vanilla, and the brewed coffee.

• What “good” looks like: Everything measured and ready to go. Mise en place, as they say.
• Common mistake: Not having everything ready. This can lead to rushing and errors.

3. Whisk Dry Ingredients: In a medium saucepan, whisk together sugar and cornstarch.

• What “good” looks like: A smooth, lump-free mixture.
• Common mistake: Leaving lumps of cornstarch. Whisk well to break them up.

4. Temper Eggs: In a separate bowl, lightly beat the egg yolks. Gradually whisk in about 1/2 cup of the milk. This is called tempering.

• What “good” looks like: The yolks are lightly beaten and starting to incorporate the milk.
• Common mistake: Adding hot milk directly to eggs. This will scramble them. Go slow and steady.

5. Combine Liquids: Add the remaining milk and the brewed coffee to the saucepan with the dry ingredients. Whisk until smooth.

• What “good” looks like: A uniform, smooth liquid mixture.
• Common mistake: Not whisking enough, leaving dry pockets.

6. Heat the Mixture: Place the saucepan over medium heat. Stir constantly.

• What “good” looks like: The mixture is warming up, but not boiling.
• Common mistake: Walking away. The bottom can scorch easily. Keep stirring.

7. Add Egg Mixture: Once the milk and coffee mixture is warm (not hot), slowly pour in the tempered egg mixture while whisking constantly.

• What “good” looks like: The eggs are incorporated smoothly without scrambling.
• Common mistake: Pouring too fast or not whisking. Again, this leads to scrambled eggs.

8. Thicken the Pudding: Continue cooking over medium-low heat, stirring constantly, until the pudding thickens. It should coat the back of a spoon. This usually takes about 8-10 minutes.

• What “good” looks like: A thick, smooth consistency that holds its shape on a spoon.
• Common mistake: Overcooking. This can make the pudding grainy or break it down. Watch it closely.

9. Add Vanilla and Butter (Optional): Remove from heat. Stir in vanilla extract and a tablespoon of butter if you like.

• What “good” looks like: Vanilla and butter are fully incorporated, adding a nice sheen and flavor boost.
• Common mistake: Not stirring enough to melt the butter.

10. Pour and Chill: Pour the pudding into individual serving dishes or one larger bowl. Cover the surface directly with plastic wrap to prevent a skin from forming.

• What “good” looks like: Pudding is smoothly transferred, and the plastic wrap is touching the surface.
• Common mistake: Not covering the surface. A skin is the enemy of smooth pudding.

11. Chill Thoroughly: Refrigerate for at least 3-4 hours, or until firm.

• What “good” looks like: The pudding is cold and set.
• Common mistake: Not chilling long enough. It needs time to set properly.

12. Serve: Remove plastic wrap and serve chilled. Top with whipped cream, chocolate shavings, or a sprinkle of cocoa powder if you fancy.

• What “good” looks like: A delicious, perfectly set coffee pudding ready to be devoured.
• Common mistake: Serving it warm or under-chilled. Patience is key.

Common mistakes (and what happens if you ignore them)

Decision rules (simple if/then)

• If the pudding seems too thin after 10 minutes of cooking, then continue cooking for another minute or two, stirring constantly, because it may need a bit more time to thicken.
• If you see tiny bits of cooked egg in the mixture, then you probably heated it too fast or didn’t temper properly because this means the eggs scrambled slightly. Strain it, but try to avoid this next time.
• If the pudding tastes a bit bitter, then you might have scorched it slightly because overheating can bring out bitterness. Try to cook more gently next time.
• If the pudding isn’t setting after chilling, then it might be too thin or not cooked long enough because cornstarch needs sufficient heat and time to activate. Consider adding a bit more cornstarch to a small portion next time or cooking longer.
• If you prefer a richer flavor, then use espresso or a very strong coffee because it will intensify the coffee taste.
• If you don’t have cornstarch, then you can try using an equal amount of tapioca starch or flour, but the texture might be slightly different because they all thicken differently.
• If the pudding seems too sweet, then next time reduce the sugar slightly because personal preference for sweetness varies.
• If you want a smoother texture, then whisk the mixture really well at every stage, especially when combining ingredients and when thickening.
• If you don’t have egg yolks, then you can try using whole eggs, but you might need to adjust the liquid slightly because yolks add richness and emulsification.
• If you want to speed up chilling, then place the pudding dishes in an ice bath for about 20-30 minutes before refrigerating, because this helps them cool down faster.
• If the coffee flavor isn’t strong enough, then next time use more coffee grounds or brew it stronger because the other ingredients can dilute the flavor.

FAQ

Can I make this coffee pudding ahead of time?

Absolutely. It’s actually best when made ahead. This gives it plenty of time to chill and set properly. Store it covered in the fridge for up to 2-3 days.

What kind of coffee should I use?

Any coffee you like! A medium to dark roast usually works well for a robust flavor. Just make sure it’s brewed strong enough so the coffee taste comes through.

What happens if I don’t cover the pudding surface with plastic wrap?

A skin will form on top as it cools. This can make the pudding less smooth and a bit unappealing. Pressing the wrap directly onto the surface prevents this.

Can I use a different thickener instead of cornstarch?

You can try tapioca starch or all-purpose flour, but the texture might change a bit. Use a similar amount, but be aware that they thicken differently and might require slightly different cooking times.

My pudding is lumpy. What did I do wrong?

Lumps usually come from not whisking the dry ingredients well enough, or from adding the eggs too quickly. Make sure to whisk your cornstarch and sugar together thoroughly, and temper your eggs carefully.

Can I make this dairy-free?

You could try using a plant-based milk like almond or oat milk, but the richness might be affected. For a dairy-free version, you’d also need to omit the butter if you use it.

How do I make it richer?

For a richer pudding, you can add a tablespoon or two of heavy cream along with the milk, or use a richer coffee like espresso. Some people also stir in a bit of butter at the end for extra silkiness.

Is it okay to use instant coffee?

You can, but the flavor won’t be as deep or complex as using freshly brewed coffee. If you do use instant, dissolve it in a small amount of hot water before adding it to the pudding mixture.

What this page does NOT cover (and where to go next)

• Advanced coffee brewing techniques for maximum flavor extraction.
• Detailed explanations of specific coffee bean varietals and their flavor profiles.
• Recipes for other coffee-based desserts like tiramisu or affogato.
• Troubleshooting for specific coffee maker models.